Becoming the Consummate Certified Security Professional Security certs won't guarantee employment, but they can help you establish
your credentials.
by Roberta Bragg
11/15/2000 --
Is there a serious shortage of information technology professionals? In the
information security world the answer is a resounding "Yes!" According to the SANS institute, an organization dedicated to network security, complete novices
are being thrust into the position of security analyst and being charged with
keeping the nation's Web sites and corporate infrastructure safe. In fact, Steven
Northcut, who founded the Global Incident Analysis Center, led the Naval Surface
Warfare Center's Shadow Team, and served as the Information Warfare Officer
at the Ballistic Missle Defense Organization, claims that "…fewer than one in
20 security professionals has the competence and foundation knowledge [on a
comparable level with their duties]."
Because of the growing need for security professionals, the popularity of security
certifications is growing as well. However, there's no magic certification to
prepare you should find yourself in the situation described above; real-world
ability and a strong grounding in a broad range of information are still what
count most. Even so, several security certifications tend to articulate these
values, and for those who are experienced, it can help you solidify your knowledge
base and stand out from among your peers.
-- advertisement (story continued below) --
Before delving into all the security certs out there, it's important to understand
the types available. Security certs tend to fall into one of two categories:
product and industry. Product certifications show that you've studied a particular
product and know enough to pass an exam provided by its manufacturer. Some of
these certifications tend to be directed toward partners (read: "sales outlets")
of the companies that sponsor them. If you work for a partner or use these security
products, see if you qualify to take the certification exam. It probably won't
land you another job, but it can't hurt.
Industry certifications tend to be a bit broader. They're usually driven by
a need to acknowledge the mastering of a commonly recognized body of knowledge
in a particular field. Most industry certifications emphasize experience before
examination and require some form of continuing education.
With all of the above in mind, let's take an in-depth look a number of viable
certification options available for security professionals.
Product-Related Security Certifications
Check Point Certified Security Administrator or Engineer Check Point Software Technologies (www.checkpoint.com),
makers of the network security product FireWall-1, offers two levels of security
administration certification for this product: Check Point Certified Security
Administrator (CCSA) and Check Point Certified Security Engineer (CCSE).
The first level is the Check Point Certified Security Administrator (CCSA).
According to the company, a CCSA understands FireWall-1 and can install and
set up simple configurations. To become a CCSA, you'll first need to choose
a track: FireWall-1 4.0 or FireWall-1 2000. Each track consists of one exam,
offered through certified testing centers. Check Point also offers training
classes. Before attending such a class, Check Point recommends that you have
working knowledge of Unix or Windows, network technology, Internet communications
and TCP/IP, as well as three months experience with the product. Benefits of
the CCSA include three free technical support incidents and access to SecureNet,
a technical reference knowledge base.
Once you've obtained CCSA, for more validity go for Check Point Certified Security
Engineer (CCSE), intended for engineers who manage multiple FireWall-1 systems.
You're expected to attend the class, "Advanced FireWall-1 Management." Here
you learn how to implement sophisticated security requirements for enterprise
networking. The company also recommends you take "VPN-1 for the Security Professional."
You must have CCSA certification and one year's experience with VPN-1/FireWall-1
to obtain the CCSE. Pass the exam and gain two support incidents during the
first year after certification and access to SecureNet. A different version
of each is available for FireWall-1 4.0, 4.1 and 2000.
Certification exams and titles exist for other Check Point products, specifically,
Certified Network Traffic Engineer (FloodGate-1) and Certified Infrastructure
Engineer (Meta IP). Certified professionals are expected to keep up with exams
on new product releases or they'll be considered retired professionals.
Cisco Certified Network Professional (CCNP) Security Specialization Cisco Systems recently announced a security specialization option
for its CCNP designation. If you're already a CCNP, you can obtain this specialization
by passing one additional exam, Managing Cisco Network Security (#640-442).
According to Cisco's Web site, the exam focuses on building and maintaining
Cisco security solutions, including standalone firewall products and IOS software
features. Cisco offers an optional training course for preparing for this exam.
Microsoft Windows 2000 Security Exam In July Microsoft introduced a new exam: Designing Security for a
Microsoft Windows 2000 Network (#70-220). This exam can serve as the required
design course or as an elective for the premium Microsoft Certified Systems
Engineer (MCSE) certification. While this exam focuses on security in Win2K,
it encompasses security design rather than taking a step-by-step approach to
using the security features of Win2K. For more information see http://www.microsoft.com/trainingandservices/exams/examasearch.asp?PageID=70-220.
Industry Certifications
Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP) and Systems
Security Certified Practitioner (SSCP) The International Information Systems Security Certification Consortium's
(ISC2) Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP) certification
covers the broadest area of knowledge of all the security certifications discussed
in this article.
The CISSP exam consists of 250 multiple-choice questions covering 10 test domains.
These domains are:
Access Control Systems & Methodology
Computer Operations Security
Cryptography
Application & Systems Development
Business Continuity & Disaster Recovery Planning
Telecommunications & Network Security
Security Architecture & Models
Physical Security
Security Management Practices
Law, Investigations & Ethics
You're given six hours to complete the exam.
Before you can sit the exam, you must subscribe to the ISC2 Code of Ethics
and have three years of direct work experience in one or more of the 10 test
domains. Examples of qualifying individuals are IS auditors, consultants, vendors,
investigators, and instructors who require IS security knowledge and the direct
application of that knowledge. The exam fee is $450 and exams are held at international
locations periodically throughout the year.
Recertification is required every three years. It's obtained by earning 120
Continuing Professional Education credits.
ISC2 also offers a Systems Security Certified Practitioner (SSCP) designation.
While the CISSP program certifies IT professionals who are responsible for developing
the information security policies, standards, and procedures and managing their
implementation across an organization, the SSCP program certifies network and
systems administrators who implement those policies, standards, and procedures
on the various hardware and software programs for which they are responsible.
Like the CISSP, it requires adherence to a code of ethics and hands-on experience
(minimum). However, it requires passing two exams: one core, and one specialty.
If you register before January 2001, you can take the core exam at this year's
price: $150.
Certified Information Systems Auditor The Information Systems Audit and Control Association (http://www.isaca.org/cert1.htm)
sponsors the Certified Information Systems Auditor certification, in existence
since 1978. This designation is often sought by IS audit, control and security
professionals.
To obtain certification, you must:
Pass the CISA exam.
Adhere to the ISACA's Code of Professional Ethics.
Submit evidence of five years of professional information systems auditing,
control or security work experience.
The four-hour exam consists of 200 multiple-choice questions. It is offered
only in June. The exam is comprehensive, covering:
Auditing standards and practices
Security and control practices
IS strategies, polices, procedures and management practices
IS hardware and software platforms
Network and telecommunications
Data validation, development, acquisition and maintenance
To get a taste, try the 25-question sampler at http://www.isaca.org/examsamp.htm.
Maintaining certification requires continuing education hours and fees.
SANS GIAC Certification To meet the needs of budding security professionals, the SANS Organization
(http://www.sans.org/infosecFAQ/index.htm) offers the GIAC Security
Essentials Certification via both Web-based instructions and a conference-based
program. Instruction covers information assurance fundamentals, IP concepts
and behavior, Internet threats, anti-virus tools, security policies, password
management and cracking, PGP, cryptography, Windows NT and UNIX security related
topics. For Level One GIAC certification, you must pass an examination and complete
a practical. The practical is an Internet-based research paper on a hack, hacker,
exploit, vulnerability attack or other important security information. The best
papers are published on the Web site (http://www.sans.org/y2k/GSEC.html).
GIAC training is not just for newbies: SANS also offers Level Two GIAC training
and certification in the following specialties:
Certified Intrusion Analyst
Certified Advanced Incident Handler and Hacker Exploits
Certified Firewall Analyst
Certified UNIX Security Analyst
Certified Windows Security Analyst
While these are not currently available via the Web, they are offered during
GIAC and SANS conferences. Demonstration of hands-on mastery of the material
as well as an examination is required. You also can become a GIAC Security Engineer
by being certified as an honors student in at least two Level Two certification
programs and completing a "sudden death" exercise.
Broader Is Better By now you know that knowledge and ability should always count
more than paper titles. Sometimes, though, you need to have both. No matter
the security designation you choose (or any certification in general, for that
matter), seek out one that reflects your real-world abilities by emphasizing
broad industry knowledge and experience. In this way, you'll help ensure the
value of your hard-won designation for a long time to come.
What's your take on security certifications? Post your comments below.
Roberta Bragg, MCSE, MCT, CISSP, runs her company, Have Computer Will Travel Inc.,
out of a notebook carrying case. She's an independent consultant specializing
in security, operating systems and databases. She is a contributing editor for
Microsoft Certified Professional magazine. You can reach her at freouwebbe@msn.com.
There are 15 user Comments for “Becoming the Consummate Certified Security Professional”
Page 1 of 2
12/6/00: Anonymous says:
Soon there will be certifications for just knowing how to turn on a computer. This is a joke. It's the industry's attempt to cash in on the paper certification craze that made other industry segments rich without actually producing many people of any real value. If you really, truly want to learn security, become a CCIE. The knowledge you will gain of networking will do you far better in network security than learning about passwords and hacks.
12/11/00: Teji says:
Oh! Yeah... I think certification had been abused by many people. It don't mean SH*T anymore.
1/11/01: Anonymous says:
Certifications only provide the employer that you have at least the basic knowledge, performance is another matter. Experience is the greatest educator.
2/26/01: JT says:
paper people have killed me!!! the only real way to lean is good old OJT. any one can read and take a test but if you do not know how to do it then what good are you?
3/27/01: Ken says:
I can see by all the anonymous posts and their content that some don't recognize the simple concept of professionalism. If the comments were worth posting it would have brought them credibility if a name would have been posted with them. I would tend to agree that the industry is getting a bit "certificaton" crazy, but some of the certifications do carry weight and value. Just becoming a CCIE does not necessarily make a person the best security professonal. That would sound like it is coming from purely a network security professional who has no experience with the broader scope of the security profession. I would assume that all the other comments are made by people that are not certified and probably based on their comments don't have the experience or qualifications it takes to become security certified, hence creating their negative viewpoint. There is some truth to cashing in, some of the certifications are making the associated companies lots of money. The only one I know of the is vendor and profit organization independent is the CISSP and the recent SSCP. To me that gives them an added level of credibility because they are vendor neutral and are maintaining a high level of certification requirements to obtain and to maintain.
3/29/01: Ms. X says:
I am enthuse anour the IT labor shortage and the IT certifications. I plan to get as many as I can plus build my experience with a reputable work ethic in this field. I resent the uninformed ignorance of blasting certifcations. This is the way to the future. Lead follow or get the hell out the way!
7/17/01: Nathan says:
The anonymous folks do have a point. And I believe the Information Security certification organizations are listening. Experience, continuing education and a solid testing program will maintain the respect these certifications deserve. Certifications are necessary, they open doors. What happens after you are through the door is dependent on your abilities. I have learned to take pride in my CISSP. It is recognized and respected in the industry. If you are an experienced Information Security professional and need to put some kick into your career, I would strongly recommend looking into the CISSP.
8/8/01: Anonymous says:
There is another Certification which could be very useful. Security track of certified Internet Webmaster ( CIW - Security Track ) Site ciwcertified.com
9/20/01: mar says:
Experience is the name people gives to their mistakes - oscar wilde.
Certifications gives you the concepts how the real things work. You cannot act on something you don't know. There is nothing wrong with certification rather it hasten your understanding of particular products, then apply it in your job.
11/6/01: Anonymous says:
Nowadays being certified has lost some of its luster.with boot camps sprouting up all over the place promising to make a student an MCSE in a matter of days is just crazy.to me they just tell you how to pass the tests.Experience is a must in this field.Having the certs along with experience makes for a well rounded I.T. Professional.On the other hand in todays tough economy having some basic certs(MCP,CNA,A+,Network+ etc)will sometimes give you an edge to get your foot in the door and show a potential employer that you have laid the necessary foundation for the higher level certifications.
Home | Microsoft® | Cisco® | Oracle® | A+/Network+ | Linux/Unix | MOS | Security | List of Certs Advertise | Contact Us | Contributors | Features | Forums | News | Pop Quiz | Tips | Press Releases | RSS Feeds Search | Site Map | Redmond Media Group | TechMentor Conferences | Tech Library Webcasts This Web site is not sponsored by, endorsed by or affiliated with Cisco Systems, Inc., Microsoft Corp., Oracle Corp., The Computing Technology Industry Association, Linus Torvolds, or any other certification or technology vendor. CiscoÆ and Cisco SystemsÆ are registered trademarks of Cisco Systems, Inc. Microsoft, Windows and Windows NT are either registered trademarks or trademarks of Microsoft Corp. OracleÆ is a registered trademark of Oracle Corp. A+Æ, i-Net+T, Network+T, and Server+T are trademarks and registered trademarks of The Computing Technology Industry Association. (CompTIA). LinuxT is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds. All other trademarks belong to their respective owners.
Reprints allowed with written permission from the publisher. For more information, e-mail editor@certcities.com