 |
 |
 |
|
 |
Greg Neilson
|
|
|
 |
 |
Great Expectations |
What's certification really worth these days? |
by Greg Neilson |
6/12/2002 -- As you might have seen from my previous columns, I'm a big believer in the value of certification. I have some myself and I'm continually encouraging my staff to keep moving on their planned certifications. However, due to the many negative comments about certification I've seen posted here and elsewhere recently, I've begun to wonder whether many people have too many expectations about its value.
A certification is a great asset. But just as the shiny new convertible depreciates the minute you drive it away, so too does your certification. Within two to four years of earning a cert, either the vendor will explicitly make it obsolete or the underlying technology has changed so much that you'll need to recertifiy to demonstrate your knowledge. Therefore, you need to be clear that once you do embark on a certification path, it won't hold its value forever and you'll need to regularly update it.
I still get e-mails from people asking about career opportunities in IT once they complete a certification program. Unfortunately these folks seem to have unrealistic expectations about the ease of entering IT, let alone the types of roles that they are qualified to perform once their certification is completed. There is no short cut to IT riches, and I'm not sure that there ever was. I don't know if it was ever true that certification alone is the ticket to earning $60-70K+, but it sure isn't the case anymore! The only way I can explain this is that, in the past, some of the really early adopters of certification had nothing but their own experience and the product manuals (if they were lucky!) to use to prepare for exams. Then, when usage of these products started booming, those folks who had extensive experience were in huge demand. In many cases they had completed the certification, but this was simply a demonstration of their theoretical knowledge -- it was their extensive practical knowledge that employers were excited about. From a distance, perhaps others got the mistaken impression that it was the certification alone that was their source of value to employers and customers, but I would have hoped that these days this myth was largely dispelled. In my work at CertCities.com's sister magazine, Microsoft Certified Professional Magazine, I know that the editorial staff have tried very hard over the last few years to pass on the message in their annual salary survey results that experience is a very important factor in the salary levels reported. However, I suspect that in many cases people are too busy looking at the dollar numbers in the tables to read any of the accompanying text!
The last area of confusion is to those who appear to confuse a certification with a career. Someone who now wants to work as a DBA on say Oracle, DB2 or SQL Server needs to know that there is so much more to these roles than just the requirements of these certification programs alone. It's one thing to know all of the wonderful commands and their switches, but it's another altogether to know what you should use in a given situation. Education and certification can assist in giving us the latest theoretical knowledge, but there's no substitute for years in the field. In this case, building a career as a DBA is not the same as completing a certification in a database product.
The same is particularly true of the developer arena. Most programming exams focus on language and class library implementation/API details, yet experience in the the art of good analysis, design and testing is probably more important in a successful career as a developer than just the code itself. In other words, just because you get an MCSD, it doesn't mean you're qualified to be an application developer.
Completing a certification can be a valuable asset in your career, but it alone won't and can't take you very far. (For anyone that thinks I'm just down on certification, I also believe that the same is true of a degree -- you really need the practical experience in combination with the theoretical knowledge to be valuable to an employer.) What do you think is reasonable to expect from a certification these days? Let me know by posting your comments below. 
|
Greg Neilson, MCSE+Internet, MCNE, PCLP, is a Contributing Editor for Microsoft Certified Professional Magazine and a manager at a large IT services firm in Australia. He's the author of Lotus Domino Administration in a Nutshell (O'Reilly and Associates, ISBN 1-56592-717-6). You can reach him at Attn: Greg.
|
|
|
 |
There are 85 user Comments for “Great Expectations”
|
Page 7 of 9
|
7/29/02: Adi says: |
Well done, Greg - you have stirred up a lot of emotions with your article. It certainly boils down to those who-have-versus-the-have-nots. Also, well done to Ron (6/21/02 - Ron) above for the most sensible and fair response. |
8/1/02: Anonymous from Incirlik Air Base Turkey says: |
6/19/02 - Kobe MCSE Talk about a lost sheep.... You would not make it past the halfway mark in a good interview, except as an entertaining joke for the office. Be for real, would love to know who hired you and for what. guess its your inexperience talking |
8/1/02: Jake from Denver says: |
Well, from my experience, education and broad work experience alone does not cut it. I have been unable to land an interview since I was laid off last December. I have done client-server, db, help desk and web development work, got an MS in MIS and can't get a job now. And no, I am no longer picky. Maybe I should have gotten certified on my own. I am in the process of catching up now and willing to part with the money, although it hurts, but I don't see any alternatives. It's just a good way to differentiate yourself from others in this lousy job market.... |
8/5/02: Grant says: |
I haven't been in IT for a long time like a lot of you seem to have been. I now have 3 years experience under my belt, and a couple of certs from different vendors. The economy is slightly different here to the US but things are still a little tight in IT. What people don't seem to understand is that there is no golden formula when it comes to landing a job. The people who are hiring you are going to have varying opinions on the value of certs vs experience just as people in this forum do. Some will trust certs, others experience. In an economy where there are far too many people and not enough jobs I don't think anyone can blame unemployment on either lack of experience or lack of certs. |
8/8/02: Anonymous says: |
I know this site, and euh... when you surf to it, all your certifications will drop with a 100% |
8/9/02: Cristian says: |
I agree with G thang. Plus if you don't have passion for this kind of job and you look only at the $ per hour thing just forget about IT... |
9/1/02: Warren says: |
I also am a paper cert (MCSA, MCSE) and was initially disappointed that there was no jobs open for me. I refused to use braindumps and studyed many long hours with and without study partners and my first few tests were difficult, trying to understand the Microsoft way of thinking. However by the time I completed the track the last test was very easy. Also important was my in home test lab giving a measure of experience and allowing me to gain confidence in my knowledge and to realisticly evaluate my skills. I would enjoy having a large income and certainly someday that will come, but I know that I am not worth 80-100K per year, but as I continue to learn and gain experience I will be soon |
9/7/02: tripnfun says: |
All I have is experience. No degree, No certs and a lot of luck. I got into the IT industry by accident. I have found that I do love it and that is why I go on doing it. I do not make the magic money or buy into the gold watch for a dollar syndrom that so many people fall into. Like every field out there that makes a lot of money (i.e. doctors or lawyers) you get a whole lot of people that try to jump in the band wagon. The problem is you never know who is serious and who isn't. I say just keep pushing yourself and you will succeed. But the $$$$$ river that everyone dreams of will only happen for a few. |
9/13/02: Eric says: |
Kobe MCSE are you kidding me? Give me a break. Your analogy couldn't have been any further off. Do you not recall the rough time Bryant had when he cracked in to the NBA? Do you not remember him alienating his teammates? Do you not remember him shooting air balls against the jazz in the playoffs with the season on the line? Sure he was a bright raw talent but he definitely needed some seasoning. Same with anyone who has nothing but a paper cert. The funny thing is that in principle I kind of agree with what your saying but your analogy is bad. People do learn at different paces but that wasn't really the point of the article. Sounds like you were venting some penned up frustration. |
9/24/02: TimZ says: |
IT is an art - so all IT guys are artists (r-TI-s), if you claim yourself good in IT - it does NOT really matters what are your degrees, certifications and year of experiences - what does matter is - if you are creating "masterpiece" - the work of art people love! |
First Page Previous Page Next Page Last Page
|
|
|
|