 |
 |
 |
|
 |
Greg Neilson
|
|
|
 |
 |
Great Expectations |
What's certification really worth these days? |
by Greg Neilson |
6/12/2002 -- As you might have seen from my previous columns, I'm a big believer in the value of certification. I have some myself and I'm continually encouraging my staff to keep moving on their planned certifications. However, due to the many negative comments about certification I've seen posted here and elsewhere recently, I've begun to wonder whether many people have too many expectations about its value.
A certification is a great asset. But just as the shiny new convertible depreciates the minute you drive it away, so too does your certification. Within two to four years of earning a cert, either the vendor will explicitly make it obsolete or the underlying technology has changed so much that you'll need to recertifiy to demonstrate your knowledge. Therefore, you need to be clear that once you do embark on a certification path, it won't hold its value forever and you'll need to regularly update it.
I still get e-mails from people asking about career opportunities in IT once they complete a certification program. Unfortunately these folks seem to have unrealistic expectations about the ease of entering IT, let alone the types of roles that they are qualified to perform once their certification is completed. There is no short cut to IT riches, and I'm not sure that there ever was. I don't know if it was ever true that certification alone is the ticket to earning $60-70K+, but it sure isn't the case anymore! The only way I can explain this is that, in the past, some of the really early adopters of certification had nothing but their own experience and the product manuals (if they were lucky!) to use to prepare for exams. Then, when usage of these products started booming, those folks who had extensive experience were in huge demand. In many cases they had completed the certification, but this was simply a demonstration of their theoretical knowledge -- it was their extensive practical knowledge that employers were excited about. From a distance, perhaps others got the mistaken impression that it was the certification alone that was their source of value to employers and customers, but I would have hoped that these days this myth was largely dispelled. In my work at CertCities.com's sister magazine, Microsoft Certified Professional Magazine, I know that the editorial staff have tried very hard over the last few years to pass on the message in their annual salary survey results that experience is a very important factor in the salary levels reported. However, I suspect that in many cases people are too busy looking at the dollar numbers in the tables to read any of the accompanying text!
The last area of confusion is to those who appear to confuse a certification with a career. Someone who now wants to work as a DBA on say Oracle, DB2 or SQL Server needs to know that there is so much more to these roles than just the requirements of these certification programs alone. It's one thing to know all of the wonderful commands and their switches, but it's another altogether to know what you should use in a given situation. Education and certification can assist in giving us the latest theoretical knowledge, but there's no substitute for years in the field. In this case, building a career as a DBA is not the same as completing a certification in a database product.
The same is particularly true of the developer arena. Most programming exams focus on language and class library implementation/API details, yet experience in the the art of good analysis, design and testing is probably more important in a successful career as a developer than just the code itself. In other words, just because you get an MCSD, it doesn't mean you're qualified to be an application developer.
Completing a certification can be a valuable asset in your career, but it alone won't and can't take you very far. (For anyone that thinks I'm just down on certification, I also believe that the same is true of a degree -- you really need the practical experience in combination with the theoretical knowledge to be valuable to an employer.) What do you think is reasonable to expect from a certification these days? Let me know by posting your comments below. 
|
Greg Neilson, MCSE+Internet, MCNE, PCLP, is a Contributing Editor for Microsoft Certified Professional Magazine and a manager at a large IT services firm in Australia. He's the author of Lotus Domino Administration in a Nutshell (O'Reilly and Associates, ISBN 1-56592-717-6). You can reach him at Attn: Greg.
|
|
|
 |
More articles by Greg Neilson:
|
There are 86 user Comments for “Great Expectations”
|
Page 8 of 9
|
9/25/02: Osam Binlayden from Afganistan says: |
I am 45 years old. I have been in IT before their they were called computers. Lets be straight here. You need certifications to get in the door, you need experience to get a raise and keep your job. The job market is over inflated and most of the companies that do the cerifications look at it as another form of revenue. Plain and simple, those are the facts. |
9/29/02: dinesh from New Zealand says: |
Hi sir, I just want to study for Linux Certifications. I had been wanting to earn a Linux certification for a long time. Can you please explain the scope of Linux certification and the kind of job oppurtunities that are available??? I'm eagerly waiting for your reply, Bye. |
10/2/02: 10-02-02-still looking says: |
I couldn't agree more on having some kind of experience, I graduated from a school and recieved my MCSE,MCSA,and MCDBA and I still cant find a job everyone keeps telling me we need some kind of experience (2 yrs. or more). What should i do , I cant just give up so I just keep sending out the resumes. Wish me luck! |
10/2/02: pradnya from pune says: |
how can i apply for mcse test ? please guide me |
10/10/02: Jesus Nieves from Los Angeles says: |
5 yrs experience MCSE Greg, Hook me up with a job in Australia. |
10/18/02: Simbicat from Canada says: |
All certifications provide is a demonstration of your desire to keep on top of the latest technologies. They certainly won't make you an expert because you went to a few braindump sites and memorized some answers. Experience counts. It is really hard to get into IT and most people have to start with a demeaning job. Isn't it like that with most careers. Being certified will not guarantee you a 70K job without having worked in a professional environment. Being an MCSE, A+, Network+, I haven't seen any changes in my salary. The exams were somewhat related to what I do in my current position. I never failed any but found them to be bogus. I think that these exams are just cash cows for MS and Comptia. The exams focus on very specific things that any network administrator could easilly check a book or Technet in the real world. The exams are designed to make you fail so that you write them again and again. Translation: more money in their pocket. |
10/23/02: jrp913 from Jacksonville Florida says: |
Excuse me, but i'm New to the IT field.People talk about College degree's,Certifications,and most of all EXPERIENCE.Sure there are pro's and con's to both College degree's and certifications, but it still takes EXPERIENCE to survive and make dreams come true.My Question is simply this: How the hell does one get an Entry Level job having the college degree(s) and or certification(s)if there are None out there or could it be that i just live in the wrong area of the USA? Someone please give me some insight to my Question. |
10/27/02: Fred from NC says: |
Excellent posts! It takes a lot of time to earn a college degree/certifications, and I don't think anyone here disputes that. It seems what a lot of us aren't realizing, though, is it's the learning process and the commitment to finish that is so important. I hold a Bachelors of Business Admin in Computer Information Systems, CCNA, CWNA, MCSA, etc. etc. and I'm currently working on a Master of Arts in Computer Information Systems. In all honesty it doesn't matter to me whether an employer regards my education, and what I've learned, as being important... I DO. It was my commitment to learn, and to finish what I started, that is so important to me. I can still recall sitting in a .50 caliber machine gun pit, under red light flashlight, during the Desert Storm era learning how to subnet. With that aside, I truly believe its experience that counts the most. I've taken a lot of menial type jobs thus far in my quest to be at the top of my game. I've been a "systems admin" for a company that was running 10base-2 with 2 Win NT 3.51 Servers and 27 DOS based nodes. Talk about a headache... I've been a computer lab tech for a local college, and I just finished out a contract as a cable modem/wireless network installer. My point is that in each one of those lower level jobs I absolutely learned things that will help me in the "real world." Do I feel like I deserve better? HELL YES! Do I feel like I'm ready to be a corporate level Systems Admin? HELL NO! My only goal right now is to get my foot in the door of a descent company that will allow me to learn their systems so that I can prove myself worthy. I spent countless hours going to college at night, and working on certs for myself in order to LEARN... not to land "the big job." I feel I will have a good job someday that pays well, and one that I can be proud to tell people what I do, however it won't be primarily certs and a degree that gets me there, and rightfully so. It will be because I've worked hard to get there and learned as much as possible along the way. |
11/4/02: Ericca from San Diego says: |
Wow, this is all too discouraging. I was looking to change careers and study for MCSE and MCSA. Is this a bad idea???? This would be a creeer change. I want to be confident in knowing that sometime after I have finished my studies that there is a deceent paying job out there that I can start my career with...... |
11/5/02: Nyert says: |
Ericca, this truly is discouraging because IT is a tough field. You have to live IT 24 hours a day every day -- you will be on call and you will have to study every night to keep up with the new technologies and associated certifications. There are no guarantees of any job waiting for you when you're ready... notice that many posters suggest working for free (volunteering) just to get enough experience to pry open the first job door. IT can also be a disappointing "career" because most companies consider IT to be a cost center, not a profit center, so they have little respect for IT workers and will lay them off in a heartbeat whenever their economies sour. So, like any other career choice, you need to decide to embark in IT only if you believe that you will truly love the work and can put up with the high hours, constant retraining, high pressure and low respect. I feel bad about being such a wet blanket, but you need to see more of the whole picture. I'd feel even worse if I knew that you entered IT with unrealistic expectations and later suffered a stress breakdown. |
First Page Previous Page Next Page Last Page
|
|
|
|