CertCities.com -- The Ultimate Site for Certified IT Professionals
Post Your Mind in the CertCities.com Forums
  Microsoft®
  Cisco®
  Security
  Oracle®
  A+/Network+"
  Linux/Unix
  More Certs
  Newsletters
  Salary Surveys
  Forums
  News
  Exam Reviews
  Tips
  Columns
  Features
  PopQuiz
  RSS Feeds
  Press Releases
  Contributors
  About Us
  Search
 

Advanced Search
  Free Newsletter
  Sign-up for the #1 Weekly IT
Certification News
and Advice.
Subscribe to CertCities.com Free Weekly E-mail Newsletter
CertCities.com

See What's New on
Redmondmag.com!

Cover Story: Secrets of the Windows Gurus

Reader Review: Word 2007 -- Not Exactly a Must-Have

Access Anywhere

Windows Vista: Learning To Play Nice

Product Review: WhatsUp Gold 11.0, Premium Edition


CertCities.com
Let us know what you
think! E-mail us at:



Visit Redmond Media Group
 
 
...Home ... Editorial ... Columns ..Column Story Thursday: October 11, 2007
TechBusiness: Resources for Innovation Through Software Technology on Redmond Developer News
Dice: The Career Hub for Tech Insiders


 Kohut's Corner  
Kevin Kohut
Kevin Kohut


 One Small Step for Certification…
Getting rid of braindump sites may be good for the industry, but in Kevin's opinion, much more needs to happen before most IT certifications can actually mean something again.
by Kevin Kohut  
2/26/2003 -- So, Robert Keppel is going to jail for his criminal actions in operating a braindump site. Now that CheetSheets.com is no longer, other braindump sites are jumping for cover (at least the ones based in the U.S.). What will all the wannabe IT pros do now? How will they get their certifications? Who will guide them through the technical labyrinth of Microsoft's tricky exam questions and confusing scenarios?

I'm thrilled to see the braindump sites starting to disappear. While I don't necessarily support the criminal prosecution of such braindumpers (seems more like a civil issue), I must admit that I'm liking the results. There's a chance now that, someday, my hard-earned MCSE will mean something again. I can just see it -- potential clients actually impressed with my certifications. Maybe we're on the long road back to the good ole' days of IT consulting!

But to get there, more has to happen. Much, much more. First off, all you existing "paper" MCSEs would need to relinquish your certs, knowing that your sacrificial efforts will help restore prestige and value to your "real-world" compatriots. Go get an entry-level job, put in your time doing the grunt work, and then let's talk about your IT skills. Or at least show me that you've done something outside the lab in your garage.

But it can go even further. I'd like to see the "legitimate" purveyors of certification exam helps recall their offerings and agree to publish only traditional how-to and reference material. What we need on the bookshelves are step-by-step guides and easy-to-look-up references, example-laden configuration manuals and "let me tell you how I did this in the real world' books. Enough of the "cram with this book and pass the test" stuff.

And all you employers of IT professionals out there, you also need to join the fray. How many times have you hired someone for an IT position based on his myriad certifications? Replace all those richly certified but actual experience-lacking individuals with true IT professionals.

Next, I want to talk to the training providers, the bootcamps, the "we'll make you an MCSE, MCDBA, and MCSD in 8 weeks" folks. You guys need to start by truly screening potential students. Oh, I know you all claim to enforce prerequisite skills, but most of you accept anyone who qualifies for financial aid. You also need to change your curricula: Don't teach to the test, but rather provide real-world skills to address real-world situations. It'd be great if you couldn't collect tuition for a student until that student actually got hired and stayed on the job for at least 90 days.

And let's not forget the companies that started this whole thing: The software and hardware vendors that implemented certification programs in the first place. Microsoft, take a cue from Cisco and develop a lab-based exam that is virtually impossible to pass unless you truly know your stuff. In fact, why doesn't Microsoft (and other companies with certification programs) simply get out of the certification business altogether? Vendor-neutral certifications haven't completely established themselves as worthy alternatives to their vendor-specific cousins, but they are finding their way into acceptance as a valid measure of IT prowess. If these could evolve into higher-level programs that truly take a neutral yet comprehensive approach to vendor technology, then we'd be getting somewhere.

Yeah, I'm glad to see these braindump sites go. But even if they all disappear, it's only one small step towards reclaiming the glory, the prestige, the practical value of my MCSE. Maybe I'll actually hang my MCSE certificate back on the wall again!


Kevin Kohut has been involved with information technology in some form or another for over 18 years, and has a strong business management background as well. As a computer consultant Kevin has helped both small businesses and large corporations realize the benefits of applying technology to their business needs.

 


More articles by Kevin Kohut:

-- advertisement --


There are 63 CertCities.com user Comments for “One Small Step for Certification…”
Page 2 of 7
3/3/03: Becky Nagel from Editor, Certcities.com says: Hey Net Guy -- Sorry about the posting quirk with our site this weekend; I removed the extra posts! Best, Becky ([email protected])
3/3/03: Anonymous says: Netguy: okay, lil' fella, you're the one who couldn't post correctly, not me, ya IT wannabe!
3/3/03: will says: i have a CNE and i have seen my CNE become valueless,,it is good just get a (degree)
3/4/03: Cdog from S.D., CA says: Kohut - I agree with your presmiss, but I don't see it as entirely practical. I cannot get into an environment where I can even touch the IOS of a Cisco router much less learn the skills of a CCIE. You just can't get there in the job market. The problem is not with the schools. As you pointed out with your Lab argument, it is with the originators of this craze, the vendors themselves. They have given the easy road to all for traveling. Granted, you cannot get a CCIE without knowing it in a real-time lab examination, but you can't get to the test without studying and passing your way to a CCNA or CCNP and getting your knees scraped a little bit in the real world to catch up on your learned terminology and how-to skills. I am great at learning this stuff in real-time and picking up complex new skills quickly, but you can't prove that in an interview. I think that all the vendors are going to have to add some complexity to the existing entry-level exams by phrasing them or designing them such that one needs to know, not the answer, but the pattern of login to pass portions of the tests. Then get Lab serious on the higher levels. That at least gives people like myself a shot at more than a simple A or N Plus to start with. And even CompTIA can make their tests more practical, up-to-date and complex to realy test skill and ability. But it has to be a concerted effort and it will take the sacrifice of some organizations losing cert revnues. That is the KEY. GET IT DONE. MAKE IT REAL. KEEP IT REAL AND PUT YOUR MONEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS. The certification is too much of a cash cow for the vendors. They need to make the sacrifice for the industry. But will they???
3/4/03: Net Guy says: To Becky Nagel: Thanks for the fast response, sorry about the foul language I saw that you edited the post a little. I also noticed that this article isn’t on the main home page any more, whats up? To much back-slash?
3/5/03: PAPER-MCSE from ALL-OVER says: Hate on us paper chasers as much as you want. IT WILL NOT CHANGE A THING. The I.T. field is dead its not about cert's anymore, its all about real college education. so EVERYBODY PLEASE STOP CRYING ABOUT YOUR CERTS!!!!SUCK IT UP AND GET A REAL COLLEGE DEGREE. Long Live Braindumps and VA benefits.
3/6/03: Anonymous says: The author of this article is forgetting that certs are just one part of the puzzle to become and IT professional. Soft skills, business skills and good attitude are more important.
3/6/03: Kevin Kohut says: To Anonymous (the one dated 3-6-03 -- and why are you folks so afraid of using your name in these posts??)--check out several of my other columns and articles on this site, and you will see that I am well aware of the many facets related to being a successful IT pro.
3/6/03: John Potater from Hawaii says: The author lives in a deluded fantasy world, and is only defensive about himself towards his detractors because he is insecure about the fact that he doesn't know much about the real world of IT work.
3/6/03: Alex from Sydney says: Why are the standards of literacy, grammar and spelling so bad in these posts from allegedly well-educated professionals?
First Page   Previous Page     Next Page   Last Page
Your comment about: “One Small Step for Certification…”
Name: (optional)
Location: (optional)
E-mail Address: (optional)
Comment:
   

top


Sponsored Links
Worried that your files and data are not safe and secure?
FREE trial of WS_FTP Server with SSH – Secure File Transfer
Exchange Email Retention and eDiscovery Best Practices
Live Webcast, October 17, Register Today!
Access your Future through Citrix Education
Obtain some of the industry’s hottest certifications
Already Microsoft, Sun, CompTIA, or Cisco certified.
Turn it into a bachelor's degree...fast!
Get 25% Off Certification Practice Exams
Introductory offer at SybexTestsuccess.com through November
Get an extra shot at Microsoft Certification.
Register for a FREE retake on your next Microsoft certification exam.
Free Microsoft, Cisco, CompTIA Exam Prep
Click Now to Download!
Capella U. IT career with a degree online.
Click here to learn about our many specializations
Get 20% off Self Test Software Cert Prep Tools
Practice tests, study guides and eLearning help you Pass the Test
Get 20% off Legendary Transcender Practice Exams
Cert prep products for Vista, SQL 2005 and NET 2.0 are here.



Home | Microsoft® | Cisco® | Oracle® | A+/Network+" | Linux/Unix | MOS | Security | List of Certs
Advertise | Contact Us | Contributors | Features | Forums | News | Pop Quiz | Tips | Press Releases | RSS Feeds RSS Feeds from CertCities.com
Search | Site Map | Redmond Media Group | TechMentor Conferences | Tech Library Webcasts
This Web site is not sponsored by, endorsed by or affiliated with Cisco Systems, Inc., Microsoft Corp., Oracle Corp., The Computing Technology Industry Association, Linus Torvolds, or any other certification or technology vendor. Cisco® and Cisco Systems® are registered trademarks of Cisco Systems, Inc. Microsoft, Windows and Windows NT are either registered trademarks or trademarks of Microsoft Corp. Oracle® is a registered trademark of Oracle Corp. A+®, i-Net+T, Network+T, and Server+T are trademarks and registered trademarks of The Computing Technology Industry Association. (CompTIA). LinuxT is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds. All other trademarks belong to their respective owners.
Reprints allowed with written permission from the publisher. For more information, e-mail
Application Development Trends | Campus Technology | CertCities.com | The Data Warehousing Institute
E-Gov | EduHound | ENTmag.com | Enterprise Systems | Federal Computer Week | FTPOnline.com | Government Health IT
IT Compliance Institute | MCPmag.com | Recharger | Redmond Developer News | Redmond
Redmond Channel Partner | TCPmag.com | T.H.E. Journal | TechMentor Conferences | Visual Studio Magazine | VSLive!
Copyright 1996-2007 1105 Media, Inc. See our Privacy Policy.
1105 Redmond Media Group