|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Great Expectations |
What's certification really worth these days? |
by Greg Neilson |
6/12/2002 -- As you might have seen from my previous columns, I'm a big believer in the value of certification. I have some myself and I'm continually encouraging my staff to keep moving on their planned certifications. However, due to the many negative comments about certification I've seen posted here and elsewhere recently, I've begun to wonder whether many people have too many expectations about its value.
A certification is a great asset. But just as the shiny new convertible depreciates the minute you drive it away, so too does your certification. Within two to four years of earning a cert, either the vendor will explicitly make it obsolete or the underlying technology has changed so much that you'll need to recertifiy to demonstrate your knowledge. Therefore, you need to be clear that once you do embark on a certification path, it won't hold its value forever and you'll need to regularly update it.
I still get e-mails from people asking about career opportunities in IT once they complete a certification program. Unfortunately these folks seem to have unrealistic expectations about the ease of entering IT, let alone the types of roles that they are qualified to perform once their certification is completed. There is no short cut to IT riches, and I'm not sure that there ever was. I don't know if it was ever true that certification alone is the ticket to earning $60-70K+, but it sure isn't the case anymore! The only way I can explain this is that, in the past, some of the really early adopters of certification had nothing but their own experience and the product manuals (if they were lucky!) to use to prepare for exams. Then, when usage of these products started booming, those folks who had extensive experience were in huge demand. In many cases they had completed the certification, but this was simply a demonstration of their theoretical knowledge -- it was their extensive practical knowledge that employers were excited about. From a distance, perhaps others got the mistaken impression that it was the certification alone that was their source of value to employers and customers, but I would have hoped that these days this myth was largely dispelled. In my work at CertCities.com's sister magazine, Microsoft Certified Professional Magazine, I know that the editorial staff have tried very hard over the last few years to pass on the message in their annual salary survey results that experience is a very important factor in the salary levels reported. However, I suspect that in many cases people are too busy looking at the dollar numbers in the tables to read any of the accompanying text!
The last area of confusion is to those who appear to confuse a certification with a career. Someone who now wants to work as a DBA on say Oracle, DB2 or SQL Server needs to know that there is so much more to these roles than just the requirements of these certification programs alone. It's one thing to know all of the wonderful commands and their switches, but it's another altogether to know what you should use in a given situation. Education and certification can assist in giving us the latest theoretical knowledge, but there's no substitute for years in the field. In this case, building a career as a DBA is not the same as completing a certification in a database product.
The same is particularly true of the developer arena. Most programming exams focus on language and class library implementation/API details, yet experience in the the art of good analysis, design and testing is probably more important in a successful career as a developer than just the code itself. In other words, just because you get an MCSD, it doesn't mean you're qualified to be an application developer.
Completing a certification can be a valuable asset in your career, but it alone won't and can't take you very far. (For anyone that thinks I'm just down on certification, I also believe that the same is true of a degree -- you really need the practical experience in combination with the theoretical knowledge to be valuable to an employer.) What do you think is reasonable to expect from a certification these days? Let me know by posting your comments below.
|
Greg Neilson, MCSE+Internet, MCNE, PCLP, is a Contributing Editor for Microsoft Certified Professional Magazine and a manager at a large IT services firm in Australia. He's the author of Lotus Domino Administration in a Nutshell (O'Reilly and Associates, ISBN 1-56592-717-6). You can reach him at Attn: Greg.
|
|
|
|
|
Post your comment below, or better yet, go to our Discussion Forums and really post your mind.
|
|
|
Current user Comments for "Great Expectations"
|
6/13/02 - Mike from says: |
As I have found out the hard way. I went to a cert school promising all the riches of those inflated salaries(didn't mention you need experiennce to obtain those salaries). Then when asked why I never see any jobs posted in the classidieds of the paper for mcse, ccna, etc.. The reply is companies do all there hiring from the Monster and other web sites( truth be told that only 1% actually do hiring from thes sites). I guess thes MCTs will have to start looking for a real job once the word gets out about the lies and false promises.. |
6/13/02 - perl from says: |
One important point, I would like to make , if u have certificate it proves u are well prepared & also serious about a domain. Like many would like to work on VC++ but doing cert (MCSD) how much committed you are. That is what will make a differance for Software firm. Just saying I am also want to work on VC++ is waste of time ... who cares ..what u talk ??? |
6/13/02 - Greg Neilson from says: |
Perl, You make a good point. I've found over time that usually the best staff I've interviewed have been certified. This leads to a chicken and egg scenario - are they good because they are certified? or are they certified because they are good? That is, the sort of person who is seriously committed to keeping their technical skills current and upgraded and is certified. |
6/14/02 - Lei Qiu from says: |
I agree with Greg, person who has certifications at least prove he(she)is committed to career and very serious about keeping technology current. The perfect combination should be education degree, working experience and tech certifications. |
6/14/02 - Patrick from says: |
Lei Qiu has hit the nail right on the head. I cannot agree more with that combination. Certification *alone* is almost suspicious without any experience. |
6/14/02 - JonH from says: |
Greg - excellent column. |
6/14/02 - John from says: |
I currently work for a Consulting and Training company and have my MCSA, MCSD, MCSE (NT/2K), MCT. Half my time is spent Training classes and the other half is consulting or development. 98% of my students have earned their MCSE or MCSD. But the most valuable part of my classes are from my "stories from the field." At the beginning of each Certification Track I always tell them that the Certs are just like a degree, it means you know the basics. But only experience will make you an expert. |
6/15/02 - Ray says: |
I currently work for a very large consulting company. During my course of employment I have met people working in other companies IT departments and it makes me wonder just how they got there. If i could stress anything its that just becuase you have your drivers licsense doesnt mean you can drive. Sure get certs but dont be paper trained. UNDERSTAND what your doing, your only hurting yourself and others can see really quick what you know and what you dont. I would suggest to anyone that you first get a entry level job in IT, something like help desk then move to certs. I hire people all the time that do not have experience or certs. I train them, give them the experience and let them get the certs. You will find that alot of places are like that. Dont look for something you know you cant do. They arent going to hire you and your wasting your time. There isnt a company i know of thats going to hire someone without experience to maintain there network. Would you bring your car to a mechanic that didnt know what he was doing??? I rest my case. |
6/15/02 - Sane from says: |
Thank God... Anyone taking certfications needs to read the above to understand what they will be getting - and hopefully ease on the whinging and whining etc. |
6/15/02 - Anonymous from says: |
College first before certifications. A BS degree in Computer Science or MIS plus some experience will open more doors and look more impressive than some paper certificate. Most employers will pay for certifications if they think that they are necessary. |
6/16/02 - obsolete MCT from says: |
this is the the "MOST REALISTIC COLUMN" I have ever read on this site....THANKS GREG!!!!thanks for opening some peoples eyes, especially mines. i better make preperations for fall semester...wish me luck everyone. |
6/17/02 - CARRIE from says: |
I AM A PAPER ORACLE DBA. I BELIEVE THAT REAL WORLD EXPERIENCES ARE MORE IMPORTANT THAN JUST GETTING CERTIFIED. IN THE CURRENT JOB MARKET, MOST OPENINGS REQUIRE FOR AT LEAST 3-5 YEARS EXPERIENCES. BUT EVERY ONE NEEDS TO BE GIVEN OPPORTUNITIES TO GET EXPERIENCES. |
6/19/02 - Blitz from says: |
Carrie, for sure, experience doesn't come cheap. Instead of waiting to be *GIVEN* the opportunities for experience, why don't you *INITIATE* the opportunities. e.g by doing volunteer jobs. What normally happened is, when the company start seeing the fruit of your volunteer labour for the company (increasing productivity/reduce cost/etc) and they have budget for additional head count, more often than not, they'll recruit you on board first before they look outside in the market. My $0.02 worth ... |
6/19/02 - RDUCK56 from says: |
Experience is extremely important. Once you have the experience, then go after the certifications and use the training whether it be via books, classroom or a home network lab or all the above to round out your rough edges and fill in the gaps in your knowledge and skillsets that you haven't acquired via experience. I started off in the Help Desk and software training route and then got an opportunity to work closely with an old time Novell CNE who was more than willing to help me and mentor me. Later when I went to another company as their PC tech and they decided to add a network to their AS400 environment I was the natural person to assume the network admin role. The VAR's MCSE again was a willing mentor to help me along as he helped my company establish their Windows network. From there I read and studied on my own to better perform my job. By the time I started working on obtaining my MCSE I had already been working with Novell and Windows NT combined for more than five years. When I got my current position as a full blown network administrator for a manufacturer my certifications helped me get myself at the top of the stack of resumes but I believe my real world experience clinched the job. |
6/19/02 - Tcat Houser from says: |
Wow. Both the article and the comments here are dead on! I don't think that Collage degree is a requirement for *everyone*, and the call here to commitment is the bottom line. I am enjoying my 38th year in MIS/IS/IT, and have no plans to stop. My avg. time for a cert test is one every 3 months.... (Yeah, I'm slowing down from 1 a month.) They are not always completely real-world, and they do demo. commitment.... (along with the home test lab). |
6/19/02 - Lou from says: |
I agree a college degree is a requirement, but is not a necessity when landing a job. The necessity is that one should not expect the high paying job which an experienced professional has earned by walking out of the education system. I have gone through a career change going from factory work to Systems Messaging Infrastructure Design & Implementation. I have a Lotus & MS certification. My first experience was as an intern during the same time period I took college classes at night. |
6/19/02 - Kobe MCSE from says: |
Bogus article, I'm a Microsoft Certified Systems Engineer which means I'm cerfitied to install, configure, manage and troubleshoot Windows Networks. So what If I don't have 5 years experience, in fact I HAVE less than a year experience. Employers still think I'm paper Certified, YA RIGHT!, If you're good, you're good, why do you need experience. Look at Kobe Bryant or Kevin Garnett from the NBA, they're both high school kids with no experience and look at them now. They didn't need experience, they were good when they got there. It's the same with IT. It's different with people, some people are faster than others. In my case, I'm an expert already. It's just sad that people devalue my MCSE cert. All I can say is if you want to be in IT, start your own business and don't rely on these employers who expect their IT canditate to be MCSE, A+, CCNA, Oracle Certifed plus a BS Computer Degree and 5 + years experience, some of these employers got to be a realistic, you can't expect to be this person all in 1. I'm just sick of these False promises especially this website and other websites that promote big bucks on getting certified and MCP magazine and their big salary surveys...BOGUS, BOGUS, BOGUS, they should be ashame with themselves. |
6/19/02 - mcdaddy from says: |
I have 19 years experience installing/maintaining/repairing computer systems. In the past two years I have obtained A+,Network+,CNA, and MCSE.I have 12 years experience installing SCO products and the seven years prior that was with proprietary O/S's. I am in the computer field because I love it. The money fluctuates and this has always beeen the nature of IT in my eyes.The Dot.com bust has hurt all of us in the IT industry, but it will bounce back again. IT people are needed in almost every business in America in some fashion or another. I have not received any monetary reward from my certification's yet, but I do feel personally rewarded in a job well done. It does take time and effort to obtain certs and I still believe they are of value. If you don't really like IT then do something else, because working in IT will mean working after hours and weekends. Just ask anybody in IT. Just my thoughts. |
Display Page: 01 02 03 04
|
|
|
more columns
|
|
|