CertCities.com -- The Ultimate Site for Certified IT Professionals
Free CertCities.com Newsletter via E-mail Share share | bookmark | e-mail
  Microsoft®
  Cisco®
  Security
  Oracle®
  A+/Network+"
  Linux/Unix
  More Certs
  Newsletters
  Salary Surveys
  Forums
  News
  Exam Reviews
  Tips
  Columns
  Features
  PopQuiz
  RSS Feeds
  Press Releases
  Contributors
  About Us
  Search
 

Advanced Search
  Free Newsletter
  Sign-up for the #1 Weekly IT
Certification News
and Advice.
Subscribe to CertCities.com Free Weekly E-mail Newsletter
CertCities.com

See What's New on
Redmondmag.com!

Cover Story: IE8: Behind the 8 Ball

Tech-Ed: Let's (Third) Party!

A Secure Leap into the Cloud

Windows Mobile's New Moves

SQL Speed Secrets


CertCities.com
Let us know what you
think! E-mail us at:



 
 
...Home ... Editorial ... News ..News Story Monday: December 27, 2010


Breaking News: Taiwan-Based Braindumpers Arrested


2/6/2004 -- The China Post is reporting today that four Taiwanese citizens have been arrested for selling IT certification exams questions through the Internet and for taking exams for other individuals.

According to the story, the four in custody -- Tung Pei-chang, 41; Hsu Ching-ping, 27; Hsiung Chih-yuan, 34; and "a man surnamed" Chang, 34 -- were arrested yesterday in various locations throughout Taiwan. Charges are fraud and copyright law.

The China Post article said that the groups sold the questions through the Web sites Test4U.net, TaipeiITtest.net and OPASScertification.net since 2001. According to the report, the sites boasted that the questions they sold were taken directly from Pearson Vue and Prometric test centers in various countries worldwide. The sites are currently offline.

It also states that in May the group began charging candidates TND $10,000 (around U.S. $300) to take exams in their place, employing a network of proxy test-takers and providing the service for about 300 clients in Taiwan.

Both enterprises resulted in revenues of around TND $5,000,000 (approximately U.S. $150,000), prosecutors say.

The China Post says that authorities were notified about the sites in Sept. of last year, but did not say whom the complaint came from.

This is the first known arrest of an overseas provider of IT certification exam questions (a.k.a. braindumps). There have been two high-profile U.S. criminal investigations, including one arrest: Robert Keppel, who owned Cheet-Sheets.com, pled guilty to a felony charge of theft of trade secrets in early 2003 and was sentenced to a year in prison. In another high-profile case, Garry Neale, then-owner of TroyTec.com and Testkiller.com, had his assets seized in June 2002 as part of a criminal investigation based on a complaint filed by Microsoft. Neale has not been charged.

These two incidents virtually quashed the U.S. braindump market, but overseas providers flourished, taking advantage of disparities between U.S. copyright laws and those in other countries, as well as the difficulties in prosecuting non-U.S. providers. This case is the first visible sign that some progress has been made on the international front.

At the Association of Test Publisher's conference earlier this week, this reporter talked to several IT certification security experts who hinted that things may be changing shortly for international braindump providers, but none referred to specific cases. Jack Killorin, Prometric's vice president of Worldwide Security, did remark in an interview that the industry has been looking at using criminal charges other than theft of trade secrets -- such as fraud, conspiracy and falsifying documents -- to pursue such cases, a tactic that has been successfully applied in at least one criminal case involving a higher-education entrance exam. "Do I care if they're charged with violating trade secrets or fraud...? No," he said. "I only care that they're behind bars."

CertCities.com is working on finding out more about this case and will bring it to you shortly. The China Post article can be found here.  -Becky Nagel



There are 68 CertCities.com user Comments for “Breaking News: Taiwan-Based Braindumpers Arrested”
Page 1 of 7
2/6/04: Tammy from Columbia Maryland says: There seems to be a thin line between what right and what's wrong. How do you separate the brain dumps from the test prep and "sample" test sites? I bought study guides from Test King once to help prepare for an MCP exam. When I sat for the certification exam, some of the same/similar questions from the guide were on the MCP exam. I was so shocked and wondered if it was illegal that it was sold to me. It made me question my knowledge of the subject and the fairness of the exams. Anyway, I know it's an ongoing issue, but it make me wonder if having the certifications really mean anything at all!!!!
2/6/04: Becky Nagel from Editor, CertCities.com says: Hi Tammy -- You're not the only one: TestKing.com was very careful at first not to say in its wording that it was a braindump, but it is. Now, most all sites are fairly blatent about it(although perhaps not after this). TestKing was (is?) owned by a person based in Pakistan, making it one of those hard-to-prosecute sites referred to above. -- Becky
2/6/04: Tammy from Columbia Maryland says: I also participated in a "fast track" MCSE "class" last year that I paid a lot of money for. (A WHOLE LOT!!) The "instructor" gave us a book that they had prepared and it was just like a big book of TestKing-like study questions. The class was to help us pass 70-210, 70-215, 70-216, 70-217, 70-218, 70-219, 70-220. I failed all exams but 70-210 and 70-215 because I really could not prepare by memorizing answers to questions!!! I decided to pack my bags and come home. I studied and prepared the correct way and I now have my MCSA and 1 exam from the MCSE. That class was last September and it has took me until this past December to get my MCSA. I know I am a smart person and I am very comfortable with my knowledge of Windows. I can't see how a person can just memorize answers and feel they can use it on the job. I cam glad they are doing something about it!!
2/6/04: mrobinson52 from Florida says: I know that we will be hearing from the Situational Ethics crowd that braindumps are no big deal, and that it is ok to use them to pass expensive tests from rich vendors, but I cannot help but rejoice to hear that the rest of the world is joining the crackdown on these providers of cheats who lesson the value of my hard earned certs! I hope that Taiwan and other countries continue to ferret out these slime merchants, and I applaud their actions! Thank you for the great news Becky!
2/6/04: Breaking News Baloney from from Headline News says: Why don't you prosecute the e-mail spammers spyware villains or virus creators. Why such bias reporting? This is not breaking news. Go ahead crack them down, but their are worse offenders and criminals in the world such as I mentioned but others like terrorist, murderers slimy degrading pornographers and drug dealers.
2/6/04: Rob from California says: I hope they can track down the names of the 300 people who got their certs through the help of this group, revoke their certs, and ban them for 20 years from retesting. This would send the right signal to potential customers and hopefully dry up the market a bit...
2/6/04: Becky Nagel from [email protected] says: Hi Breaking News -- The label isn't meant to imply any sort of bias. The reason it was labeled that way is that 1) the story came out today; 2) this is major news for those following the braindump situation ; and 3) I'm working on a more in-depth follow-up article, making this one the one that "breaks" the news. Hope that helps explain it some. Best, Becky
2/6/04: washuu from Germany says: Interesting ! Someone busted for copyright violation IN Taiwan? Till now everyone said that Taiwan does not accept international copyright law. So for a Taiwanese it is (or was?) not illegal to sell ANY bootleg copy of ANYTHING to another Taiwanese resident in Taiwan. Only buyers who are not Taiwanese or don't live in Taiwan could be prosecuted. Has this changed ? Good news then :-))
2/6/04: Breaking News Baloney from from Headline News USA says: Get real the world! Becky They might get a slap on the wrist. Misdemeanors maybe! Confiscation of material Yes. There are far worst problems in the world in and out of IT world. Enron defrauders, company theft, export of IT jobs overseas. Jack Killorin of Prometric's says "Do I care if they're charged with violating trade secrets or fraud...? No," he said. "I only care that they're behind bars." What do you want the death penalty? Then send Jack and Rob there too!
2/6/04: Certified from Houston says: In all of the coverage of Garry Neale's Troy Tec, why hasn't anybody mentioned that he actually sold study guides? He sold 30-40 page study guides that were really good. He didn't need to sell test questions of dubious origin. He could have sold the study guides without the questions and made money without getting in trouble.
First Page   Next Page   Last Page
Your comment about: “Breaking News: Taiwan-Based Braindumpers Arrested”
Name: (optional)
Location: (optional)
E-mail Address: (optional)
Comment:
   

-- advertisement (story continued below) --

top