Security+: Get with the Basics This exam isn't designed to have much depth, but it does cover a wide range of security topics relevant to networking professionals.
by Andy Barkl
11/6/2002 --
As you may have noticed, in the past 18 months a greater emphasis has been
placed on computer and network security. As part of that, security certification
has become more popular, any many new titles are popping up to capture this
interest. One of these is the vendor-neutral, entry-level Security+ from the
Computing Technology Industry Association (CompTIA).
Most CompTIA exams are written for those relatively new to the IT industry,
and generally scratch only the surface of the technology covered. Security+
is no exception. It will test your knowledge on a wide-range of security related
topics, but it doesn't go into any real depth. CompTIA recommends two years
of networking experience for this exam. I personally recommend some hands-on
security experience, if only to give you the chance to work with many of the
tools and techniques covered on this exam -- some will be hard to master without
understanding the practical application. Even so, armed with one of the many
Security+ study guides that will soon flood the market, I believe most people
with the recommended level of experience will find the exam on the easy side.
Content Overview The final version of the Security+ exam has not yet been released
(CompTIA has said only that it will go live in late 2002). I took the beta version
earlier this fall. It contained 125 multiple-choice questions and lasted two
hours. When released, the live exam will contain fewer questions and cost around
$199 (U.S.). To earn the certification, candidates must pass this one exam.
Once earned, Security+ certification is good for life.
Security+ features five main objective areas:
General Security Concepts (30 percent)
Communications Security (20 percent)
Infrastructure Security (20 percent)
Basics of Cryptology (15 percent)
Operational/Organizational Security (15 percent)
Most of the domains seemed equally weighted on the beta exam, but there are
certainly areas that can get more obscure than others. The following should
give you a general idea of what's covered by each. (A detailed list of the exam's
objectives can be found here.)
General Security Topics
General security concepts are just that, general. For instance, what is the
recommended minimum length a user's password should be? What network attack
method includes the attacker calling a user and pretending to be from the company's
support staff? Is it a virus or a Trojan horse that replicates itself from system
to system using various techniques? What is a form of two-factor authentication?
Tip: If you're new to security topics, an excellent book that can
get you up to speed in this area is "Computer Security Basics" from
O'Reilly.
-- advertisement (story continued below) --
Communications Security
This domain can include slightly more obscure topics. It will help if you're
well-versed in today's network security protocols. Do the acronyms VPN, RADIUS,
TACACS+, L2TP/PPTP, SSH, and IPSEC mean something to you? You need to know these
protocols (and many others) plus their uses to pass this domain. For example,
make sure you know the advantages of a VPN and how to create one, which remote
access protocols can be used to centrally authenticate users, and which OSI
layer the various protocols operate at.
Infrastructure Security
This domain requires that you understand firewalls, routers, switches, wireless
devices, modems and intrusion detection systems, to name a few. CompTIA also
expects candidates to be able to field questions regarding TCP port numbers,
access-control techniques, and of course, methods for securing wireless and
other devices.
Other objectives within this domain include securing network media, removable
media, security topologies, security baselines and application hardening. Can
you answer questions like: What is the most secure network media available?
What are the methods used to secure data on removable media? Is a DMZ a form
of a secure network topology? How can you create security baselines? If you
remove ActiveX controls, is that a method of application hardening? As you can
see, this domain is a step-up from the first two, but still not too difficult.
Basics of Cryptology
Now it's time for some real fun. This domain includes objectives for security
algorithms and hashing. You'll also find concepts of cryptology, standards and
protocols, and key management/certificate lifecycle objectives. This is where
you'll need some of that network security experience that CompTIA didn't tell
you about but I think is required. Simply studying the different security algorithms
such as MD5, SHA, DES, 3DES and RSA will only leave you asking, what was that?
You really need to setup a lab where you can experiment with the different encryption
methods and truly understand the concepts behind each. After all, what fun is
it if you can't walk the walk?
The other half of this domain includes the PKI objective of certificates. Here
again you'll need to be familiar with the practical side of things, including
certificate issuance, revocation, expiration, suspension, renewal and destruction.
If you're running a Windows 2000 server network in your lab, it's fairly simple
to install and build a Certificate Server and get the hands-on experience that
you'll need for this section.
Operational/Organizational Security
This is where you'll find some of the more interesting objective areas
such as physical security, disaster recovery, forensics, education, and documentation.
Well, O.K., not all of them are very exciting, but a few are. For example, my
favorite is forensics. Investigation and gathering of evidence, to find wrongdoing
to prevent further misuse can be exciting. Of course, most of the time you may
be doing nothing more than securing the system to prevent accidental damage.
Physical security includes controlling access to systems and data, such as
the server room. Make sure you know all the methods used to control physical
access, such as card readers and biometrics.
For the disaster recovery section, you need a fairly solid understanding of
the baseline techniques and procedures. You should also be familiar with data
backup and restore strategies.
With business continuity, organizations will put in place public media relations
experts in case a network attack occurs. Then there are natural disasters that
can disrupt the business continuity. Should you install your hot site within
the same geographic boundaries as your primary site?
Policies and procedures are always a tough thing to deal with and get users
to adhere to. You should be familiar with the reasons for policies and procedures
and the necessities of writing, maintaining and enforcing them.
User education is one of the primary responsibilities of any network security
person or team, and the advantages of awareness campaigns to promote user compliance
are tremendous. Most network security problems or attacks in today's networks
are internal, and many of the problems can be attributed to user errors. Training
and education both need to play a bigger role in many of our corporate networks.
Documentation is the final objective in this domain -- usually the last thing
anyone ever completes. However, well written, complete and up-to-date documentation
can make the difference between an ad-hoc network and one that is truly secure.
Preparing for Security+
Along with the recommended experience, CompTIA recommends (but does not require)
that you hold its A+ and Network+ certifications. I don't agree that you should
have A+ -- there's not much crossover here -- however, Network+ may be a good
idea for some, especially considering Security+'s heavy coverage of TCP/IP.
As I mentioned earlier, a flood of Security+ study guides is heading our way.
But if you don't want to wait for the market to shake these offerings out, you
can always pick up a more general security title. Auerbach
publishing offers a few titles, including the popular "Information
Security Management Handbook." Sybex
also has many security titles available, as do a wide variety of IT publishers.
Personally, I prefer the Auerbach books. While they're not designed to be used
as exam study guides, they contain the information you need and are also excellent
for technical reference.
Security+ preparation classes may also become widespread. But you can also
take a more general security class. I recently attended a course from SANS.
This organization has many courses to choose from, including Security Essentials,
which is designed for the new security person. SANS is also another resource
for security-related books.
Getting Secured
I think Security+ will be used by many to gauge one's awareness and basic understanding
of network security. It could even be used by employers for select user groups
as part of a security awareness campaign. At the very least, the exams and/or
the study guides developed for it should be required for an organization's technical
and support staff.
There are other security certifications available on the market today, but
most of them are geared towards the higher-level IT professional with the word
security in their job title. Security+ is for the rest of us, and does what
it's designed to do -- serve as a way to test baseline knowledge of this important
topic.
Andy Barkl, CCNP, CCDP, CISSP, MCT, MCSE:Security, MCSA:Security, A+, CTT+,
i-Net+, Network+, Security+, Server+, CNA, has over 19 years of experience in
the IT field. He's the owner of MCT & Associates LLC, a technical training
and consulting firm in Phoenix, Arizona. He spends much of his time in the classroom
but has also been responsible for many Microsoft Windows 2000, Exchange 2000,
and Cisco networking deployments for many clients across Arizona. He's also
the online editor for MCPMag.com, TCPMag.com, CertCities.com, and a contributing
author and editor for Sybex and Cisco Press. He hosts a multitude of exam preparation
chats monthly on MCPmag.com, TCPmag.com and CertCities.com. You can reach him
at andy.barkl@wetrainit.com.
There are 57 user Comments for “Security+: Get with the Basics” The current user rating is:
Page 1 of 6
12/13/02: Anonymous says:
More difficult than the CIW security professional exam.
12/19/02: Anonymous says:
Less difficult that the ISC2 CISSP exam. Although that exam is also a cakewalk.
1/27/03: Anonymous says:
Thanks for the review. It's pretty easy if you know your stuff.
2/25/03: Anonymous says:
very difficult
4/8/03: Anonymous says:
Don't rely on the Sybex book for a good test prep.
5/21/03: Jerry from New Jersey says:
Take your money to the track. The horse running in the third race is a better bet.
I used the TestTakers Book, Exam Cramm and Transcenders. About 7 out of 10 questions were easy and found in the books. (Transcenders was not much help with this one.)
You need 764 out of 900 to pass. If all questions are equally weighed, that would be just under 85% correct. If you get a few poorly worded questions, a CompTia special, and get hit with a few concepts that did not stick, it's really easy to miss the mark.
Unless you really need this certification, I would consider putting my money and efforts elsewhere.
6/5/03: Anonymous says:
I passed the CISSP no problem but have failed this exam after doing practice exams, reading books and working with security on a daily basis! Poorly worded questions and some security concepts that are a poor evaluation of knoweledge.
6/6/03: Blaizze from Chicago says:
This exam requires a lot of soul searching. I sat for it twice already, and still no dice. You most definately need to bring your "A" game for this one. I would'nt say the questions are poorly worded all that much, because I managed to get within 5% of nailing it. I guess its not too bad considering I have no IT experience. Its going to depend on how bad you want it.
Good Luck!
6/9/03: Kristofor from Denver says:
Very good Exam from CompTia. I was really surprised how difficult it was. Dont rely on Sybex or Mike Myers book. I used CISSP book to study for this one!!
Home | Microsoft® | Cisco® | Oracle® | A+/Network+ | Linux/Unix | MOS | Security | List of Certs Advertise | Contact Us | Contributors | Features | Forums | News | Pop Quiz | Tips | Press Releases | RSS Feeds Search | Site Map | Redmond Media Group | TechMentor Conferences | Tech Library Webcasts This Web site is not sponsored by, endorsed by or affiliated with Cisco Systems, Inc., Microsoft Corp., Oracle Corp., The Computing Technology Industry Association, Linus Torvolds, or any other certification or technology vendor. CiscoÆ and Cisco SystemsÆ are registered trademarks of Cisco Systems, Inc. Microsoft, Windows and Windows NT are either registered trademarks or trademarks of Microsoft Corp. OracleÆ is a registered trademark of Oracle Corp. A+Æ, i-Net+T, Network+T, and Server+T are trademarks and registered trademarks of The Computing Technology Industry Association. (CompTIA). LinuxT is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds. All other trademarks belong to their respective owners.
Reprints allowed with written permission from the publisher. For more information, e-mail editor@certcities.com